Browse Auditing and Attestation (AUD)

Reporting on Financial Statements Prepared Under Special-Purpose Frameworks

Feb 7, 2025

How auditors report on cash, tax, regulatory, contractual, and other special-purpose accounting frameworks.

On this page

Special-purpose framework reporting appears on the AUD exam because the auditor’s report must make the accounting basis clear. The financial statements may be fairly presented under the cash basis, tax basis, regulatory basis, or contractual basis, but users must not confuse that basis with GAAP.

The audit question is not simply whether the numbers are correct. The auditor must decide whether the framework is appropriate for the users, whether the statements describe the basis clearly, and whether the auditor’s report needs an emphasis-of-matter paragraph or restricted-use wording.

    flowchart TD
	    A["Financial statements use a non-GAAP basis"] --> B["Identify the framework"]
	    B --> C["Evaluate appropriateness for intended users"]
	    C --> D["Audit recognition, measurement, and disclosure under that basis"]
	    D --> E{"Could general users misunderstand the basis?"}
	    E -- "Yes" --> F["Emphasis-of-matter paragraph draws attention to the basis"]
	    E -- "No" --> G["Report still names the framework clearly"]
	    F --> H{"Contractual or regulatory basis for specified parties?"}
	    G --> H
	    H -- "Yes" --> I["Consider restricted-use wording"]
	    H -- "No" --> J["Ordinary distribution may be appropriate"]

Common Special-Purpose Frameworks

A special-purpose framework is a basis of accounting other than GAAP that is designed for a particular reporting purpose.

Framework Core idea Typical users or purpose Exam cue
Cash basis Record cash receipts and cash disbursements. Closely held entities, lenders, owners focused on cash flow. Receivables, payables, and accruals may be absent.
Modified cash basis Cash basis with selected accrual-type modifications. Small or private entities needing limited extra information. Modifications must be logical and clearly disclosed.
Tax basis Use principles used for filing the entity’s income tax return. Owners, tax preparers, lenders comfortable with tax-basis statements. Depreciation, revenue timing, and expense recognition may differ from GAAP.
Regulatory basis Use accounting rules prescribed by a regulator. Insurance, banking, utility, or other regulated industries. Report may be intended for the regulator or specified parties.
Contractual basis Use accounting rules specified in a contract. Lender, grantor, franchisor, or contractual counterparty. Use is often restricted to the parties to the agreement.

The auditor audits the statements against the selected framework. A tax-basis statement is not misstated merely because it differs from GAAP, but it can be misstated if it does not follow the tax basis as described.

Auditor Responsibilities

The auditor must understand the basis of accounting before designing procedures. The most important work areas are:

  • Determine whether the framework is acceptable for the engagement circumstances and intended users.
  • Obtain an understanding of how management applied the framework.
  • Test amounts and disclosures against the framework actually used.
  • Evaluate whether the financial statements adequately describe the basis of accounting.
  • Consider whether any title, note, or presentation could imply GAAP when the statements are not GAAP-basis.
  • Determine whether the auditor’s report should restrict use.

The description of the basis matters because special-purpose statements can omit items that GAAP users expect. For example, cash-basis statements may omit receivables and payables, while tax-basis statements may use tax depreciation methods that differ from GAAP depreciation.

Reporting Requirements

The auditor’s report should identify the special-purpose framework and direct users to the note describing that basis. When the basis differs from GAAP, the report commonly includes an emphasis-of-matter paragraph that draws attention to the basis of accounting.

Reporting issue Auditor response
Statements are prepared on cash, tax, or another special-purpose basis Name the framework in the report.
Users may assume the statements are GAAP-basis Add an emphasis-of-matter paragraph directing users to the accounting-basis note.
Framework is contractual or regulatory and intended for specified parties Consider restricted-use wording.
Disclosures are inadequate for the special-purpose basis Request correction; modify the opinion if the statements remain materially misstated.
Presentation suggests GAAP conformity when GAAP is not used Require clearer titles, notes, and report language.

An emphasis-of-matter paragraph does not modify the opinion if the statements are fairly presented under the special-purpose framework. It highlights the basis so users understand the reporting context.

Restricted Use

Restricted-use wording is most likely when the statements are prepared under a contractual or regulatory basis for specified users. The concern is that other users may not understand the purpose, limitations, or criteria used in preparing the statements.

Cash-basis or tax-basis statements are not automatically restricted. The auditor decides based on the framework, intended users, and whether general distribution would be misleading.

Application Examples

Fact pattern Likely treatment
A small business prepares tax-basis financial statements for its owners and lender. Report identifies the tax basis and includes an emphasis-of-matter paragraph directing users to the basis note.
An insurance entity prepares statutory-basis statements for a state regulator. Report identifies the regulatory basis and may restrict use to the regulator and specified parties.
A borrower prepares covenant-basis statements under a loan agreement. Auditor evaluates the contract criteria and usually restricts report use to the borrower and lender.
A cash-basis statement title says “GAAP financial statements.” Management should revise the title because it misstates the basis.
Tax-basis statements omit the note describing the basis of accounting. Auditor should request disclosure; unresolved omission may require opinion modification.

Exam Traps

  • A special-purpose framework is not automatically a departure from the applicable basis; it is the basis.
  • A cash-basis or tax-basis report can be unmodified if the statements are fairly presented under that basis.
  • The emphasis-of-matter paragraph highlights the basis; it does not make the opinion qualified.
  • Restricted use is most common for contractual or certain regulatory bases, not every special-purpose framework.
  • The auditor still applies audit procedures; the engagement is not a compilation or preparation engagement merely because the basis is non-GAAP.

Quick Review

Use this sequence for SPF reporting questions:

  1. Identify the basis of accounting.
  2. Decide whether the basis is appropriate for the intended users.
  3. Audit recognition, measurement, and disclosure under that basis.
  4. Check whether the basis is clearly described in the financial statements.
  5. Add report language that names and emphasizes the basis.
  6. Consider restricted use for contractual or regulatory reports.

Review Questions

### Which statement best describes a special-purpose framework? - [ ] A reporting framework used only by SEC issuers. - [x] A basis of accounting other than GAAP designed for a specific reporting purpose. - [ ] A prohibited basis that always requires an adverse opinion. - [ ] A compilation format that cannot be audited. > **Explanation:** A special-purpose framework is a non-GAAP basis such as cash, tax, regulatory, contractual, or another basis appropriate for specified reporting needs. ### What is the auditor primarily evaluating in an audit of tax-basis financial statements? - [ ] Whether the statements comply with GAAP. - [ ] Whether the statements include every GAAP disclosure. - [x] Whether the statements are fairly presented in accordance with the tax basis described. - [ ] Whether the statements can be filed as Form 10-K financial statements. > **Explanation:** The auditor audits the statements against the selected special-purpose framework, not against GAAP unless GAAP is the applicable basis. ### Why is an emphasis-of-matter paragraph commonly used in special-purpose framework reports? - [ ] To modify the opinion whenever GAAP is not used. - [x] To draw attention to the note describing the special-purpose basis. - [ ] To state that no audit procedures were performed. - [ ] To replace management's responsibility for the statements. > **Explanation:** The paragraph alerts users to the basis of accounting without modifying an otherwise unmodified opinion. ### Which framework is most likely to require restricted-use wording? - [ ] Cash basis used by a small business for broad lender distribution. - [ ] Tax basis used by owners and a bank familiar with the entity. - [x] Contractual basis prepared solely for a borrower and lender under a loan agreement. - [ ] Modified cash basis used for internal management reporting only. > **Explanation:** Contractual-basis reports are often intended only for specified parties who understand the agreement's criteria. ### What should the auditor do if cash-basis statements are titled as GAAP financial statements? - [ ] Ignore the title if the numbers are accurate. - [x] Require clearer presentation because the title may mislead users about the basis. - [ ] Automatically disclaim an opinion. - [ ] Convert the engagement to a review. > **Explanation:** Titles and notes must not imply GAAP conformity when the statements use a special-purpose framework. ### Which item would typically be absent from pure cash-basis statements? - [x] Accounts receivable. - [ ] Cash receipts. - [ ] Cash disbursements. - [ ] Bank account balances. > **Explanation:** Pure cash-basis statements generally recognize cash activity rather than accrual-basis receivables and payables. ### If special-purpose framework disclosures are materially inadequate, what is the auditor's likely response? - [ ] Issue an unmodified opinion because special-purpose statements need no disclosures. - [ ] Add a management representation paragraph instead of changing the report. - [x] Request correction and modify the opinion if the statements remain materially misstated. - [ ] Treat the issue as a scope limitation in every case. > **Explanation:** Inadequate disclosure can make the financial statements materially misstated under the applicable framework. ### Which statement about tax-basis financial statements is correct? - [ ] They are always restricted to the Internal Revenue Service. - [ ] They are always adverse because they differ from GAAP. - [ ] They require no note describing accounting policies. - [x] They may receive an unmodified opinion if fairly presented under the tax basis. > **Explanation:** A tax-basis audit opinion can be unmodified when the statements follow the tax basis and include adequate disclosures. ### What makes modified cash basis acceptable in many engagements? - [ ] It randomly mixes GAAP and cash-basis rules. - [x] Its modifications are logical, consistently applied, and clearly disclosed. - [ ] It eliminates the auditor's need to test balances. - [ ] It is required for all nonpublic companies. > **Explanation:** Modified cash basis can be acceptable when the modifications are coherent and transparent to users. ### Which question should the auditor ask before deciding whether to restrict use? - [ ] Did management request a shorter report? - [x] Are the criteria intended only for specified parties who understand the framework? - [ ] Is the engagement fee below a certain threshold? - [ ] Did the entity choose cash basis instead of tax basis? > **Explanation:** Restricted use depends on whether the report is intended for specified users and whether broader users may misunderstand the criteria.
Revised on Monday, June 15, 2026
Interim Reviews